Item #3094 Typed Letter Signed [TLS] on the Nature of God. ALBERT EINSTEIN.
EINSTEIN, ALBERT.

Typed Letter Signed [TLS] on the Nature of God

“I believe that the idea of a personal God is too anthropomorphic and childlike to be considered seriously.”

ONE OF EINSTEIN’S MOST DIRECT STATEMENTS ON GOD: A POWERFUL AND CONCISE PRECURSOR TO HIS CELEBRATED “GOD LETTER”.

In the letter, dated September 25, 1948, and addressed to the Indiana University student Barbara Homans, Einstein writes:

“I believe that the idea of a personal God is too anthropomrphic [sic] and childlike to be considered seriously. We have to content ourselves with that modest insight which is accessible to us.”

The letter is a strikingly concentrated statement of Einstein’s religious philosophy. In two sentences, he rejects the notion of an anthropomorphic personal deity while setting against it a characteristically modest view of human knowledge: rather than claiming access to metaphysical certainty, “we have to content ourselves” with the limited understanding available to us.

That formulation places the letter squarely within one of the most important recurring themes of Einstein’s later correspondence: his distinction between conventional belief in a personal God and his own sense of awe before the rational order of the universe. Six years later, in his famous letter to the philosopher Eric Gutkind of 3 January 1954, Einstein would return to the same subject in far greater detail, describing the word “God” as an expression of human weakness and rejecting traditional religious conceptions with exceptional directness. Christie’s described the Gutkind letter as Einstein’s most fully articulated statement of his religious and philosophical views; it sold in 2018 for $2,892,500 at Christie’s.

The present letter is remarkable because the essential position of the later “God Letter” is already present here in distilled form. The shared target is the anthropomorphic personal God: a conception Einstein repeatedly rejected while maintaining that a profound sense of wonder before the structure of nature could still be called religious.

It is a direct statement of Einstein’s mature religious philosophy, anticipating the central argument of the 1954 “God Letter” by more than five years.

Typed letter signed (“A. Einstein”) to Barbara Homans. Princeton, 25 September 1948. One page (8 1/2 x 11 in), typed on Einstein’s Princeton stationery, with embossed address at head; signed “A. Einstein” in ink. Folded for mailing, with light toning and a few small stains.

Price: $150,000 .

See all items in Science & Technology
See all items by ALBERT EINSTEIN